03 October 2012
Doyle Delights: Less delight, more dull--CBS's Elementary falls short
And, boy is he famous! In an earlier blog, I wrote about the resurgence of Holmes via the Downey Jr./Law Warner Brothers movies and the Cumberbatch/Freeman BBC series. American television has now decided to throw their deductions in the ring with CBS's Elementary, starring Jonny Lee Miller as the great detective and Lucy Liu, as a female "Joan" Watson. Good news: Elementary is not BBC's Sherlock. Bad News: Elementary is not that great of a television show.
At its core, Elementary is an American police procedural made for an American audience. So, my beef is why call the character Sherlock Holmes at all? The only things Sherlockian about the show is Miller's British accent, a brief mention of beekeeping, and a police captain called Tobias Gregson. Bringing this Holmes to New York City and "modernizing" him in this way has stripped the character of Sherlock Holmes to an unrecognizable, unimaginable, and uninteresting detective. Canonical (and well adapted on-screen Holmes') are far different from this warm, humanistic Holmes. Elements of this Holmes simply seemed off. Holmes does eventually become a warmer person (over 50+ stories and 4 novels) but it is does not happen until later, and its moments are fleeting. Holmes would have never said that he hates it when he's right, on the contrary, he loves it! He does not "spare feelings", he is brutally honest. I certainly don't consider myself to be a Sherlockian canon purist, but this one strays a bit too far for me.
Having a Sherlock Holmes, there must be a Watson. John or, in this case, Joan...it didn't really matter to me. A female Watson works, it's fine; however, once again when an adaptation goes too far from the original source then something isn't right. Joan Watson is certainly not Dr. John Watson in more than their difference in gender. One: she is no longer a doctor. Watson needs to be a doctor, in some capacity. I just didn't buy the "sober companion". She has no military background. Watson needs a military experience, Watson needs to be ready for their adventures, if there are any "adventures" in Elementary. These two main pieces of Watson's character have been taken away, not to the detriment of the show, but to the detriment of the character. As with Holmes, when one takes away the essential elements of a character there is no reason to call them those names.
Luckily Elementary's Sherlock Holmes has a British accent. Then his name might best be Greg House. Jonny Lee Miller's Holmes is by far the least traditional Holmes I've ever seen on screen. Un-kept with a five-o-clock shadow certainly doesn't fit my image of the gentleman that is Sherlock Holmes. It is just the pilot, but Miller didn't quite seem comfortable with fast-paced dialogue and seemed to make odd, erratic movements appear unatural. There are some actors that can pull off fast-paced dialogue (i.e. David Tennant's and Matt Smith's Doctors 10 and 11, or even Rathbone's, Brett's, Downey Jrs., and Cumberbatch's Holmes'). Unfortunately, it felt as if Miller was trying too hard. Liu is the type of actress that could play a Holmes-type character. I felt she was too limited in the "sidekick" role, and as it turned out made her own interesting deductions. She is definitely more than a conductor of light and that may prove to be a problem as well. In the end, Miller and Liu's performance did not convince me of an immediate friendship that Holmes and Watson shared. It is likely one that will grow over time.
If Elementary brings new readers or brings people back to the canon, then I couldn't be any happier. But, will the differences be too much? Will readers wonder why Holmes is in London? Why Watson is a male and ex-military? Why isn't Gregson in more stories? Time will only tell.